Key takeaways
- People have diverse perceptions of their early career experiences, with varying views of the roles played by privilege, need, and luck in their outcomes.
- Participants in this study placed less emphasis on personal responsibility and individual effort when recounting their early experiences in the labour market.
- Different aspects of a person’s identity, such as gender, race, disability, or income, shape their experiences of advantage or disadvantage.
Plain language summary
This study provides intersectional insights into how young people perceive their early career experiences. Researchers interviewed people aged 18 to 35 in Ontario to learn how they perceived their early career outcomes and what they believed had influenced them. Participants focused on three main factors: privilege, need, and luck. Intersectional characteristics were found to influence how they discussed these factors.
Discussions of privilege focused on the economic and social advantages—such as family connections, financial support, and education—that some participants had when entering the labour market and navigating early-career transitions. The intersectional aspect of the discussions allowed participants to reflect on the complexity of privilege and the challenges that stem from different aspects of one’s identity.
Greater need—such as due to financial constraints or personal responsibilities—was associated with more pressure to accept lower-quality employment, including work with lower pay or little job security. The study frames these decisions as practical career decisions that people make so they can balance work with other responsibilities. However, such choices can create further disadvantage for an individual’s future career. The discussion of need reflects the feeling of limited personal power or choice in employment.
Finally, participants sometimes attributed their employment outcomes to good fortune rather than to other factors, such as need or privilege. For some, this framing downplayed the efforts they had made to find work or the disadvantages they faced, such as having to accept a job with limited benefits, security, or opportunity. For others, attributing their success to luck seemed to minimize the advantages they enjoyed, potentially obscuring the role of privilege in their career outcomes.
Overall, the study provides an intersectional lens for better understanding how individual characteristics may affect people’s perceptions of their early careers.
Why the results matter
For post-secondary, education, and training professionals
This research provides further understanding of how young people explain their early career outcomes, which can be useful for framing the role and importance of education and experience.
For career, employment, workforce, and economic development professionals
The research provides insight into how some young people view the drivers of their early-career outcomes and how their personal identity affects these views. This information is useful for framing recommendations and advice for young people as they navigate the labour market.
For workers, job seekers, and learners
This research draws attention to the different ways in which young people may interpret and characterize success in their early careers. Understanding these differences can help young workers better understand the factors that may have influenced them.