Key takeaways
- Based on 10 years of data, immigrants working in trades who arrived in Canada as children or youth earned less than their Canadian-born peers.
- Although the results varied by trade type and socio-demographic characteristics, the overall earnings gap was evident before certification and persisted afterward, even after accounting for other factors.
- The evidence suggests that salary growth trajectories are not significantly different.
- The findings highlight the need to examine the challenges of accessing and progressing in the trade industries to ensure equitable pathways to success.
Plain language summary
This study looks at how childhood immigrants (those admitted to Canada at age 17 or younger) fare economically versus their Canadian-born counterparts after they become certified journeypersons in the skilled trades. Because childhood immigrants typically complete their education and training in Canada and have time to develop English or French proficiency, they are often thought to face fewer barriers than adult immigrants. Theoretically, these advantages should narrow wage gaps. However, the study’s findings suggest they do not eliminate them.
Using linked data on journeypersons who were certified from 2008 to 2018, the study tracks median employment income at five points:
- four years before certification
- two years before certification
- the year of certification
- two years after certification
- four years after certification
Childhood immigrants made up only 3% or so of certified journeypersons and were more likely to be women, to live in Ontario or British Columbia, and to work in the automotive, hairstyling, or cooking trades. They were less likely to hold union jobs or have workplace pensions. They had lower median incomes at all five comparison points. In fact, the gap grew from pre-certification to certification: they earned $4,700 less than Canadian-born journeypersons four years before certification, with the gap peaking at roughly $8,500 less during the certification year. The gap then narrowed modestly to about $7,800 less four years post-certification.
Canadian-born journeypersons generally earned more than childhood immigrants in industrial and mechanical trades, with the gap most pronounced among heavy-duty equipment mechanics, who earned $6,700 to $10,500 more, depending on the point in their certification journey. However, childhood immigrants had higher median incomes than their Canadian-born counterparts in several other trades, including cabinetmaking, carpentry, painting and decorating, roofing, and welding.
Adjusting for socio-demographic, program, trade, and employment characteristics narrowed the gap, but did not eliminate it. Childhood immigrants earned about 9% less than their Canadian-born peers four years before certification and 6% to 7% less at later points. Characteristics that could be controlled for explained only about a third of the raw gap, with regional differences, pension coverage, union coverage, sex, and trade mix contributing most. Both union membership and pension coverage were linked to substantially higher earnings. Women earned roughly 20% to 28% less than men.
Earnings growth post-certification was similar for the two groups. Median income growth was slightly higher for childhood immigrants (17% versus 15% at two years and 21% versus 19% at four years). After adjustment, earnings growth was about 1% lower at two years. The difference was not statistically significant at four years.
In other words, childhood immigrants started from and stayed at a lower earnings level, but did not fall further behind after certification. The authors suggest that demand for a trade may play a role, given that earnings gaps may be smaller where workers are scarce.
Why the results matter
For the public sector
For policymakers, studies like this are important for examining the barriers to success for certain groups and ensuring equitable outcomes.
As the authors suggest, the study may inform policies aimed at supporting skilled trades training pathways, labour mobility, and earnings equity for population groups that may encounter challenges with respect to accessing and advancing in the trades. Identifying a gap guides informed discussions about the types of barriers that explain it as well as the types of interventions that can reduce it.
Recent economic turbulence due to tariffs has the potential to exacerbate precarity in employment and labour market outcomes for these groups, further underscoring the need to address this issue.